"Look at the legalized adultery we call divorce.
Men marry one wife after another and are still admitted into good
society; and women do likewise. There are thousands of supposedly
respectable men in American living with other men's wives, and thousands
of supposedly respectable women living with other women's husbands."
- R. A. Torrey From R.A. Torrey's book How to Pray, pages 94-95
R.A. Torrey (1856-1928) was a very well-known Christian writer,
evangelist, pastor, graduate of Yale University, and was also the
superintendent of Moody Bible Institute for 19 years.
TRINITY BARS THE
DIVORCED.; No Remarriage in the Church or Any of the Chapels.
The clergy of Trinity Church announced yesterday that under no
circumstances will divorced persons be married by any of the clergy of
that Episcopal parish, nor will such marriages be permitted either in
the church at Wall Street and Broadway or in any one of the parish's
eight chapels. The announcement was as follows:
View full article New York Times
December 7, 1904, Wednesday
Comment/question
Homosexual marriage is wrong for reasons other than being outside the
marriage covenant. God's plan for marriage is for one man - one woman,
for life - barring the aforementioned exceptions of abandonment by an
unbeliever, or adultery. These were mentioned in scripture by Jesus and
Paul, and we do disagree over interpretation, but they WERE said and
they DO exist. You cannot explain them away.
Response
Homosexual marriage is just as much outside the will of God as is
adultery. For me, it's hard to understand how many in today's church
believe that what Jesus called adultery (having unlawful relations with
another's spouse) is entering into a covenant marriage. How is that any
different than a homosexual getting married, believing they are blessed
in God's eyes? Neither homosexual marriage nor adultery constitute a
marriage covenant. A piece of paper does not make it so. Just because WE
say we're joined in marriage and it's lawful in God's sight, does not
mean it's true. In fact, unless we can find it in God's Word that His
approval is upon such a relationship, I think we ought to stick with His
last words on the topic.
Comment/question
I read the article you pointed (name deleted) to. I find it "typical" of
the remarriage articles out there that always bring in homosexual unions
when discussing heterosexual adultery and remarriage. I don't know why
they do that other than to sway the reader in their reading of the
entire article.
Response
Interesting that you got out of that article what you did. He, the
pastor, WANTS to see homosexuals embraced in the church---while they
continue their homosexual relationships. He speaks on the history of the
church's belief on divorce/remarriage. I found it interesting that he
compared remarriage to homosexuality-----not as a person who is against
remarriage, but as someone who has seen it accepted when it previously
was REJECTED and agrees with accepting remarrieds serving in churches.
He says Pastors used to not marry divorced persons. Now they
overwhelmingly do. They didn't marry divorced persons because they USE
to see it as adultery and they didn't want to be guilty before
God...........He goes on to say "what changed?"...............Culture
changed. Because divorce and remarriage has grown, now marrying divorced
people has become acceptable........he is hoping that because of this
turn of tide, that someday soon people will also begin to accept
homosexual couples into their congregations and allow them to serve God
and man in these "blessed" unions.
What
this article did for me was CLEARLY show how sin desensitizes and then
causes cloudiness/blindness to the truth. The truth that marrying a
divorced person is adultery is clearly seen in scripture, yet many "SEE"
the scriptures, yet they look outward to find the truth (look at
situations and people). The scriptures are very CLEAR on the sin of
homosexuality, yet more and more in the "church" are starting to accept
active lifestyles that contradict the Word of God because now they know
the PEOPLE and like them---again, external is ruling over the Word of
God.
Comment/question
Try again... Marriage is between a man and a woman (according to the
Bible) so the homosexual analogy is not correct.....
Response
Adultery was just as stoneable an offense as homosexuality was in the
OT. Are you saying that adultery now is Ok with the Lord and that He
even "joins" it as a lawful marriage?
Comment/question
The Bible says: "If we confess our sins He is faithful and just to
forgive us our sins, and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness".
Response
Can a practicing homosexual confess and remain in their illicit
relationship? Can an unmarried couple remain in fornication if they
"confess" their sin? Can a couple who are related to each other that
have gotten married stay married and continue to commit incest? Where do
we draw the line on illicit relationships (as defined by God).........
Comment/question
Even the blind can see that you're throwing the same kind of question
that the Pharisees were in Matt 19. There's no where in Scripture old or
new Testament where it's suggested implied, and FOR THIS reason: (taking
in consideration his audience and the heart of the questioner HE did not
addressed that question) ever appropriate for 2 people of the same sex
to form any kind of God-honoring family union.
come on now...!
Response
Ok, so you say that the Lord does not honor
same sex relationships as being a God honoring family
union.............yet you seem to be saying that a union that the Lord
has called adultery IS a God-honoring family union? Since both types of
relationships in the OT brought about the death sentence, why is it you
think one type ok to continue, but not the other?
Comment/question
I don't think it's the same. Homosexuality by
it's very nature is not a real marriage period but this is not based on
previous marriages but rather the same-sex aspect. In regards to folks
simply living together, what we tell them is to get married or move out.
Preferably the former. Marriage is what brings honor to the relationship
of those living together.
Response
Asking a homosexual couple that is legally
married (according to the laws of the land) with children to break up is
EXACTLY like asking a couple to stop their relationship who are living
in what the Lord calls adultery, but the law calls them "married". All
the same emotional sufferings are there---for the adults and the
children involved. All the same tangible worries are there. One
relationship is called homosexuality----a perversion of the marriage
covenant............the other is called adultery----a perversion of the
marriage covenant created by God. In the first instance, "strange flesh"
is being joined----that the Lord does not join. In the second, someone
else's spouse is being taken. Again, there is no evidence in the
scriptures where God joins what He calls sin.
Comment/question
If homosexuality is going to be used as a
comparision to remarriage after divorce as adultery, then, why when God
allowed divorce as a concession for the hard heartedness of His people,
didn't he also do so for homosexuality? It seems even God may have
graded one sin as greater than the other, wouldn't you think?
Response
Yes, I've heard some say that homosexuality is
worse than adultery to the Lord. However, in the OT Law BOTH were
stoneable offenses, so I believe God thought both sins were detrimental
to His people.
Comment/question
Homosexual relationships cannot be marriages –
sorry, God classifies this relationship as an abomination by itself.
You cannot continue to use homosexual
relationships as this example.
Response
I agree that homosexual relationships cannot
be marriages---in God's sight. However, I will continue to keep using
that example as well as incestual relationships and such because ALL
sexually prohibited relationships are sinful to the Lord. What He calls
adultery is just as sinful and a perversion to what He created as
homosexuality is................as has been noted before: homosexuality
as well as adultery were BOTH stonable offenses. If it was God Himself
who called for such a judgment/punishment to be meted to the guilty, I
believe He STILL views them both as sinful-------though now there is
GRACE to repent and change one's choices in life-----if one is willing
to accept the Grace offered to them.
Comment/question
I will repeat on this one. This is not a discussion regarding same sex
unions. Homosexual "marriages" are not even addressed in Scripture.
There is no issue concerning marriage or divorce between homosexuals
because homosexuality is condemned in Scripture period. Same sex
marriages are a civil issue until they come to the church.
Response
You're ignoring my question. You said," (divorcing if the second
marriage was born of sin). There is not one place in Scripture where
that is commanded and yet this is what people are saying God says".
If divorce is not mentioned in scripture concerning adulterous unions,
and divorce concerning homosexual marriage is also not mentioned in
scripture, then BOTH sexual unions, you are saying ,can be STAYED
in----yes?
Comment/question
There can be no valid same sex marriages in the eyes of the Lord since
there is no such thing as an intimate relationship like this between the
same sex.
Response
There absolutely IS intimate relations with same sex unions, just like
there absolutely IS intimate relations with ADULTEROUS unions. Yet, you
say one is ok, one is not ok. The OT law condemned BOTH types of
relationships. Do you now believe Jesus oks adultery, but not
homosexuality?
Comment/question
But what we do see in Deut 24 is an instance of a woman being divorced
and once remarried, is banned from returning to the ex husband. That is
written and that is why I can deal with it in this thread. I think you
should really avoid the whole homosexual argument because it has nothing
to do with this thread at all.
Response
You don't want to deal with the homosexual issue because there ARE
correlations between the two types of illicit relationships. BOTH
destroy the one man/one woman for life family that God created-----that
is why God called for the stoning of those who would pervert the
creation intent for marriage. Thankfully, through Jesus, we can now
forsake our sinful unions and LIVE.
As for Deut. 24, can you show me where the woman who marries another man
is charged with adultery as is the case in the NT teachings of Jesus and
Paul? Not apples to apples. Jesus clearly shows a HUGE change from OT
practice to NT practices. The interesting thing is that we see that in
Hosea 2, Gomer speaks of returning to her FIRST
husband................We also see that God is speaking against Deut.
24, in Jer. 3:1......."they say................but I say
to you, return unto me"
Comment/question
As I said this is not a thread
asking about the validity of same-sex unions in the eyes of the Lord so
I do not have to deal with it even if you believe there are
correlations. There is a thread dealing with that somewhere I'm sure. I
choose to stick with divorce and remarriage as I see in the Scriptures.
Response
You were the one speaking about an unlawful union and the disposition of
it (adulterous unions and you feeling that since scripture doesn't tell
exactly what to do in that ONE particular sinful union, then one must
assume that the Lord thinks it ok to stay in it). I'm merely using
another sinful union to show that your reasoning is flawed. Scripture
tells us to flee immorality and to forsake sin. The Lord has called
remarriages, adultery------sin. Nowhere in scripture do we see this
sinful relationship being called lawful in the Lord's sight. Nowhere in
scripture do we see that confession turns an illicit relationship into
something lawful.
Comment/question
If you believe there is a
correlation between a homosexual union and a marriage between a man and
woman, then I don't know what to tell you.
Response
The correlation is between homosexuality and what the Lord calls adultery.
It seems to me that you won't call a relationship what the Lord calls
it............you call it something else. The truth is that the Lord
says in His word that one CAN'T be bound to a new spouse if their
covenant spouse is still alive----that is why joining with another is
called adultery-----by the Lord.
Comment/question
There is no place in Scripture
where we find a case of married homosexuals where they are given
guidelines on the proper way to divorce so that all is fair and civil.
It's not dealt with in Scripture for a reason and that's the same reason
I feel no need to deal with it here.
Response
Is there detailed scripture for ANY kind of divorce proceeding in the
NT(fair and civil, as you say), since you believe divorce is OK in some
instances of heterosexual covenant marriages? If not, then why do you
believe divorce is ok in those type marriages, since scripture does not
spell out how to do a fair and civil divorce?
Comment/question
Homosexuals and fornicators are
not in a covenant marriage so one can not compare them to a husband and
wife. Husbands and wives can also be forgiven if they have committed the
sin of adultery just as the homosexuals and the fornicators can be
forgiven. No one here can tell me what sins the blood of Jesus does not
cover in true repentance? Apparently some of you here feel adultery is a
unforgivable sin even when one has repented so you are making the
blood of Jesus useless! Jesus came to save sinners in the world.
Response
Yes, Jesus does forgive the husband or wife who commits
adultery...........when they forsake their adultery----which
is the fruit of TRUE repentance. If we want to see "false" repentance we
have a picture of that in Mal. 2. The Lord rejected his
offerings.........and called the first wife, the wife of the covenant.
Also, Jesus does not say people who remarry are in a covenant marriage,
He says they are committing adultery by joining together. It can only be
adultery because He views the ones in the first marriage as still bound
to each other.
Listen to our sermons and radio broadcasts online!
Add Spirit of Hosea sermons and radio broadcasts to your webpage
with the FLAM mp3 player below.
Get the mp3 player code for your webpage HERE
Whenever our sermons are updated, they automatically update in the player on your webpage.
A Preacher's Repentance From Adulterous Remarriage.
The Testimony of J.M Humphrey
Tony Sexton's Repentance From Remarriage Adultery
More Testimonies of Repentance From Adulterous Remarriage & Messages of Encouragement
Frequently Asked Questions, Comment, Arguments About Marriage Divorce & Remarriage
Sermons & Radio Broadcasts on marriage, divorce, remarriage & more.
Orville Swindoll
A
Fellowship, Support & Discussion Forum
Theological Foundations
has an online fellowship and discussion forum for those who
are standing for their covenant marriages and for those who
have repented of adulterous remarriages.
The Hosea Project is an international, nondenominational
effort by volunteers to contact each Pastor and leader of
the Christian Church worldwide with this message of
repentance and restoration.
Listen to the Hosea Project message
Looking for a church that teaches the permanency of marriage?
I do NOT in any way endorse the entirety of a number of these sites below, nonetheless, they may contain useful information and/or resources.
Critique
of David Instone-Brewer on Divorce
By Dr. Leslie McFall
Former lecturer in Hebrew and Old Testament. Now a full-time researcher in
Biblical Studies.
Former Research Fellow at Tyndale House Library (Cambridge, England).
**More MDR links at